Armed vs Unarmed Security Guards: Which Does Your Property Actually Need?

Table of content

Choosing between armed vs unarmed security starts with one question. What could go wrong at your property, and how serious could it get? For most offices, apartment communities, HOAs, warehouses and construction sites in Southern California, an unarmed guard is the right choice. A visible, trained guard stops most problems before they start and calms down the rest. Armed guards make sense when the risk is higher, such as cash, cannabis, high-value goods or a history of violence. This guide is for the property manager or business owner who wants the right protection without paying for more than the site needs. It covers when each type fits, what California requires, what each costs and how to check a guard’s license.

Key takeaways
  • Most properties in Southern California are well served by unarmed security guards.
  • Armed guards make sense for cash handling, cannabis, high-value goods and sites with a history of violence or credible threats.
  • Every California security guard needs a BSIS guard card. An armed guard also needs a BSIS firearms permit, which requires a firearms course, range qualification and a passed assessment.
  • A concealed carry permit alone does not let a guard work armed. A guard who carries a concealed firearm on duty needs both a CCW and a BSIS firearms permit.
  • At West Coast Security & Patrol, unarmed guards cost $24 to $35 an hour and armed guards cost $35 to $45 an hour.
  • The choice should follow a risk review of your site, and a licensed security company can do that review with you.

The quick answer

If your site hasUsually the right choiceWhy
Offices, apartments, HOAs, front desks, most retailUnarmed guardA visible, trained guard deters most problems and de-escalates the rest
Construction sites, warehouses, parking lots after hoursUnarmed guard or mobile patrolTheft and trespass are the main risks, and presence and patrols handle them
Cash handling, cannabis, jewelry or high-value inventoryArmed guardValuable targets can attract armed criminals
A history of violent incidents or credible threatsArmed guard, after a risk reviewThe guard may face an armed threat
Events with alcohol or large crowdsMostly unarmed, sometimes a mixCrowd control depends on numbers and training more than firearms

What armed and unarmed guards do

Both types do the same core job. They deter crime by being seen. They watch, report and control who comes in. They patrol the property and respond when something happens. Both write reports and follow written post orders that list their duties at your site.

The difference is the firearm, and the training and licensing behind it. An armed guard carries a handgun on duty and has met extra state requirements to do so. Unarmed does not mean untrained. Every California guard completes 40 hours of state-required training in the first six months on the job and 8 hours every year after that.

Armed vs unarmed security guards side by side

The table below shows the difference between armed and unarmed security guard coverage in California, from licensing to cost.

| Unarmed guardArmed guard
California licenseBSIS guard card
Minimum age18
Training40 hours in the first six months, then 8 hours every year
West Coast Security & Patrol rate$24 to $35 per hour
Best forDeterrence, access control, patrols, customer-facing posts
Feel on siteApproachable, blends in with tenants and customers
Stakes in an incidentLower

The unarmed training is set by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (BSIS). A new guard completes 8 hours before registration, covering the power to arrest and the appropriate use of force. Another 16 hours follow within 30 days and 16 more within six months.

An armed guard adds a firearms course of about 14 hours, with 8 hours in the classroom and about 6 on the range. Since July 1, 2018, a guard seeking a first firearms permit must also pass an assessment of judgment, restraint and self-control before applying.

Unarmed security guard checking a visitor in at an office lobby desk
At offices and lobbies, a front desk officer checks visitors, helps tenants and watches the entrances.

When an unarmed guard is the right choice

An unarmed guard fits most sites where the main risks are theft, trespass, vandalism, loitering and people who need to be asked to leave. Common examples:

  • Offices and lobbies. A front desk officer checks visitors, helps tenants and watches the entrances.
  • Apartment communities and HOAs. Patrols, parking rules and gate checks. See gated community and HOA security.
  • Retail with low to moderate theft. A visible guard deters shoplifting and helps customers.
  • Construction sites at night. Theft and trespass are the main risks. See construction site security.
  • Warehouses and distribution centers. Gate checks, yard patrols and dock rounds.
  • Hospitals and clinics. De-escalation matters more than force in a care setting.
  • Schools and places of worship. A calm, approachable presence keeps people at ease.

Police response time matters too. If officers can reach your site quickly, an unarmed guard who observes, reports and calls for help is usually enough. Our unarmed security guard services cover all of these site types.

When you should consider an armed guard

Armed coverage makes sense when the people or property you protect could draw an armed attacker. These are the warning signs:

  • Cash handling. Banks, check cashing stores and businesses that move cash. See bank and financial institution security.
  • Cannabis. Dispensaries and grow sites often hold both cash and product. See cannabis security.
  • Jewelry and other high-value retail. Small, valuable goods attract organized thieves.
  • A pattern of serious incidents. Armed robbery, assaults or repeated break-ins that current security has not stopped.
  • Credible threats against people. Threats against executives, staff or patients after a dispute or termination.
  • Isolated sites. Remote properties where police help is far away.
  • High-risk events. Large crowds with high-profile guests or a history of trouble.

An armed guard should follow a risk review, not a feeling. A firearm changes how an incident plays out and raises the stakes for everyone, including the guard. When the risk is real, our armed security guard services put licensed, permitted officers on site.

Armed security guard on post with firearm holstered at a business entrance
Armed coverage fits sites that handle cash, cannabis or high-value goods, or that have a history of violence.

Questions to ask before you decide

Answer these six questions about your site. A yes to any of the first four points toward armed coverage. The last two are checks to make before you decide.

  1. Do you handle cash or keep high-value goods on site?
  2. Have there been violent incidents at the site in the past year?
  3. Have staff or tenants received credible threats?
  4. Is the site isolated, or is police response slow in your area?
  5. Do your lease, landlord and insurer allow armed guards on the property?
  6. Would an armed guard change how customers, tenants or visitors feel?

If every answer to the first four is no, an unarmed guard is almost always the better fit.

What armed coverage costs compared with unarmed

At West Coast Security & Patrol, unarmed guards cost $24 to $35 an hour and armed guards cost $35 to $45 an hour. How much armed security costs at your site depends on the hours, the number of posts and the risk.

Here is a simple example. One guard working 40 hours a week covers about 173 hours a month.

Guard typeHourly rateAbout 173 hours a month
Unarmed$24 to $35About $4,160 to $6,070
Armed$35 to $45About $6,070 to $7,800

For one full-time post, armed coverage adds roughly $1,700 to $1,900 a month. These are examples, not quotes. Overtime, holidays and extra posts change the total. Many sites keep costs down with a mix, such as an armed guard at the cash office and unarmed guards at the entrances.

How to check a guard’s license in California

Ask the security company for each guard’s guard card number. For armed guards, ask for the firearms permit too. Then check both on the DCA license search, where BSIS licenses are listed. Check the company’s private patrol operator license there as well. West Coast Security & Patrol holds PPO License #120329.

Three details matter for armed security guard requirements. The firearms permit lists the calibers a guard has qualified with, and the guard may carry only those. An armed guard must work in a uniform with an approved badge and patch. A concealed carry permit from a sheriff is not a security firearms permit. A guard who carries concealed on duty needs both.

Ask for the company’s certificate of insurance too. California requires every private patrol operator to carry at least $1,000,000 in general liability insurance for each occurrence.

California guard card and firearms permit with personal details blurred
Ask for each guard’s card number and, for armed guards, the firearms permit. Then check both on the DCA license search.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between armed and unarmed security guards?

Both deter, observe, report and control access. An armed guard also carries a handgun and holds a BSIS firearms permit, which takes extra training, range qualification and an assessment.

Do banks have to use armed guards?

No federal law requires it. The Bank Protection Act requires banks to adopt security procedures and name a security officer, but the choice of guards is left to the bank. Many banks still use armed guards based on their own risk review and policy.

Can an unarmed guard stop a crime?

Often, yes, mostly by being seen before anything happens. When something does happen, an unarmed guard observes, reports and calls police. California guards are trained in the power to arrest, which is the same citizen’s arrest power any private person has.

What does an armed security guard need in California?

A BSIS guard card, a BSIS firearms permit and the age of 21. The permit requires a firearms course, a written exam, range qualification and a passed assessment.

Is an armed guard a liability risk?

Any firearm on site raises the stakes. Ask the company about its training, use of force policy and insurance, and check that your own insurer and lease allow armed coverage.

Can I mix armed and unarmed guards at one site?

Yes. Many sites place an armed guard where cash or high-value goods are handled and unarmed guards at entrances, front desks and patrol routes.

Get Armed or Unarmed Security in Southern California

West Coast Security & Patrol provides armed and unarmed security guards across Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside and San Bernardino counties. Not sure which you need? Tell us about your site and we will recommend the right level of coverage with a free security quote. We answer the phone 24 hours a day at 1 (800) 484-7062, or you can request a quote.

California PPO License #120329.

Share

Related Insights